Your phone’s location history could link you to a federal investigation, even if you did nothing wrong. Geofence warrants allow investigators to search for phones near a crime scene. This can include phones carried by people who had no role in the crime. If authorities use this data against you in Chicago, you may have grounds to challenge it.
How do geofence warrants identify suspects?
Most search warrants target a known person or place. Geofence warrants work differently. They seek location data from phones near a crime scene. In the past, agencies such as the FBI obtained Google’s Sensorvault records in three steps:
- Google provided anonymous device identifiers and location records.
- Investigators selected devices for additional location information.
- Google disclosed identifying account details for a narrower group.
Google now stores much of this data on users’ devices instead of its own servers. However, older records obtained through these warrants may still raise privacy concerns under the Fourth Amendment.
Can geofence evidence violate the Fourth Amendment?
In June 2026, the Supreme Court held that investigators conducted a search covered by the Fourth Amendment when they obtained Google’s stored location data. It left lower courts to decide if the warrant clearly limited the search and was backed by probable cause.
If prosecutors rely on such evidence, your defense may examine:
- Warrant scope: Whether the warrant was too broad and failed to clearly state what investigators could search.
- Search area: Whether investigators had enough evidence to justify the time and area covered by the warrant.
- Location errors: Whether GPS or Wi-Fi data placed your phone at the wrong location.
Accuracy disputes can weaken the evidence without establishing an unconstitutional search.
What if you face federal charges involving location data?
Location records cannot, by themselves, establish who carried a phone or committed a crime. Before trial, your defense may seek to exclude unlawfully obtained records through a motion to suppress. Even if a court finds a warrant invalid, it may still allow the evidence under the good-faith exception. This applies when officers had a reasonable basis to rely on the warrant. However, the exception does not apply if the warrant was so clearly flawed that no reasonable officer could rely on it.
If you receive a federal target letter or face federal charges involving geofence evidence in Chicago, contact Gal Pissetzky promptly to discuss your defense and possible suppression options.
Frequently asked questions
Q: Can federal prosecutors use a geofence warrant if they do not have a suspect?
A: Yes. That is precisely how geofence warrants work: law enforcement asks a judge to force Google to turn over location records for all devices within a geographical area during a specific timeframe, allowing agents to identify potential suspects in reverse.
Q: Are geofence warrants legal in Illinois federal courts?
A: The law is heavily contested. Federal judges evaluate whether the warrant established probable cause and described the target location with sufficient particularity. Several federal courts have declared overly broad geofence warrants unconstitutional violations of the Fourth Amendment.
Q: Can a criminal defense lawyer get geofence evidence thrown out?
A: Yes. By filing a motion to suppress, your attorney can challenge whether the warrant was an impermissible general search, whether the perimeter swept up innocent people and whether agents exceeded their legal authority.

